718-896-0777 info@realtydepotny.com
logo
  • Home
  • Listings
    • Our Listings
    • Our Rentals
    • Search Properties
    • Open Houses
    • Sold Properties
    • Rented Listings
    • List With Realty Depot
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Blog
    • List With Realty Depot
  • Our Agents
  • Testimonials
  • Contact Us
  • Fair Housing Notice

Single Family House for Sale in Shelter Island, Suffolk County, NY 11964 | Web ID: 842673 | $9,955,000

 
Single Family in Shelter Island - Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-2Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-3Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-4Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-5Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-6Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-7Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-8Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-9Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-10Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-11Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-12Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-13Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-14Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-15Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-16Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-17Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-18Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-19Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-20Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-21Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-22Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-23Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-24Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-25Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-26Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-27Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-28Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-29Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-30Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-31Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-32Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-33Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-34Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-35Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-36Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-37Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-38Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-39Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-40Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-41Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-42Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-43Single Family Menantic  Suffolk County, NY 11964, MLS-842673-44
 

Property Description

For The First Time In Over A Century, This Extraordinary Collection Of Generationally Owned Properties Is Being Offered Together As A Singular And Rare Opportunity. Nestled Along The Serene And Picturesque Menantic Creek, These Three Separate Parcels Combined Total 4.9 Acres, Which Have Been Combined Into One Sale, Presenting An Unrivaled Waterfront Retreat. The Menantic Creek, Known As Hurricane Hole For Boat Protection During Storms, Offers Boating Access To Both The North And South Forks And A Short Run To Montauk. For The Boating Enthusiast, This Offering Includes A 100-foot Stationary Dock, Complete With A 6-foot-wide Walkway With A Bench, As Well As A 12-foot Plastic Ramp Leading To A 30x6 Ft. Floating Dock With Three Anchor Pilings. Two Moorings On The Creek Are Also Available, Pending Reapplication. At The Heart Of This Offering Is 15a Menantic Road, A Legally Designated Two-family Residence With A Breathtaking 3, 944 Square Feet Of Meticulously Renovated Living Space. This Refined Home Features Five Bedrooms, 4 Plus 2 1/2 Baths, And A 483-square-foot Garage, All Thoughtfully Designed To Maximize The Stunning Creek Views. Taxes: $12, 206.00 Adjacent To This Residence Is 15 Menantic Road, A Pristine And Vacant 1.3-acre Parcel, Offering Endless Potential To Further Enhance This Exceptional Estate. Taxes: $4, 325.00 Completing The Trio Is 13 Menantic Road, A Charming 1930s Bungalow With Two Bedrooms And One Bath Set On 1.47 Acres And A Brand New Two Story 4 Bedroom, 2.5 Bath Home With Attached Two Car Garage In The Final Stages Of Completion. Taxes: $8, 521.00 What Truly Sets This Estate Apart Is Its Extraordinary Arboretum-like Setting, Adorned With A Curated Collection Of Rare And Mature Specimen Trees, Including Copper Beech, Southern Magnolia, White Birch, Monkey Puzzle, Dawn Redwoods, Linden, Osage Orange, Red Japanese Maple, And Dogwood. The Natural Beauty Of This Land Is Simply Unparalleled. This Is A Once-in-a-lifetime Opportunity To Own A Waterfront Compound With Limitless Potential—a Legal Multi-family Residence, A Historic Bungalow, A New Construction Home And An Untouched Parcel—all In One Of The Most Coveted Locations. A Truly Rare Find For The Discerning Buyer Seeking Exclusivity, Natural Beauty, And Unparalleled Waterfront Living.

Property Information

Location/Town Shelter Island
Area/County Suffolk County
Prop. Type Single Family House for Sale
Style Contemporary
Tax $25,052.00
Bedrooms 9
Total Rooms 16
Total Baths 6
Full Baths 4
3/4 Baths 2
Year Built 1983
Basement Partially Finished, Storage Space
Construction Frame
Cooling Central Air
Heat Source Electric
Util Incl Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected, Trash Collection Private, Water Connected
Features Basketball Court, Basketball Hoop, Boat Slip, Dog Run, Garden, Mooring, Playground, Rain Gutters
Patio Deck, Patio
Days On Market 62
Lot Features Back Yard, Cleared, Front Yard, Garden, Level
Parking Features Driveway, Garage, Shared Driveway
Tax Assessed Value 1808000
School District Shelter Island
Middle School Shelter Island School
Elementary School Contact Agent
High School Shelter Island School
Features First floor full bath, eat-in kitchen, entrance foyer, formal dining, primary bathroom
Listing information courtesy of: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

RealtyDepotNY

Tel: 718-896-0777
Cell: 347-219-2037
Fax: 718-896-7020

 

 

View This Property on the Map

MORTGAGE CALCULATOR

Property Value
Downpayment
Loan Amount
Number of Years
Interest Rate
Annual Taxes
Annual Insurance
Mortgage:
Total Payment:
Note: web mortgage-calculator is a sample only; for actual mortgage calculation contact your mortgageg provider
footer-logo

Contact Us

Please feel free to contact us with any questions, or concens.  We are happy to answer any questions that you may have...

  • 103-13 Queens Blvd., Forest Hills, NY 11375
  • Email: info@realtydepotny.com
  • Phone: 718-896-0777
  • Fax: 718-896-7020

Links

  • Home
  • Our Listings
  • Our Rentals
  • Search Properties
  • Open Houses
  • Sold Properties
  • Rented Listings
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • List With Realty Depot
  • Our Agents
  • Testimonials
  • Contact Us

Featured Listings

Apartment For Rent 2bdr 1bath Welcome To The Monaco! The Monaco Is A Very Well Maintained Ren...
  ... Read More
Apartment For Rent 1bdr 1bath Renovated Extra Large One Bedroom In Classic Pre-war Building With...
  ... Read More
Apartment For Rent 2bdr 1bath Gorgeous Huge Nicely Renovated Junior4  rental In Forest Hill...
  ... Read More